I'm sort of biased to this Irani cafe because I've spent most of my college hours here. Eaten while working on projects or always met friends here.
Do try the chicken cuggets, chicken and cheese omelette, keema pav, mutton salli boti, chicken farcha, cherry cold custard, raspberry soda, chicken puff, mutton pattice and of course the bun maska and chai.
It's a typical Irani with flies and all, however nothing is really unhygienic and the food is good quality.
However, I know a lot people who don't quite get the ethos of Irani cafes and hence may not like the grunge look.